‘Superman vs. the Myth of Aristocracy’ on Tor

“Thus, by action and by example, Superman embodies a populist ideal, that it doesn’t matter who one’s parents are, no one can impose their will on the world. And it doesn’t matter how powerful one is, it matters how one chooses to use that power.”

From a nice post on Tor.com here.

It’s interesting that I’ve never really liked Superman; I haven’t particularly enjoyed reading any of the comic books, and didn’t think any of the films were up to much. I think the reason is that I’ve always found the character to be a little disappointing, for the very reason the author of the essay says he’s great: the fact that he has it within his power to completely remake Earth society, to be the benevolent dictator of a global utopia where no-one needs to worry about war, or famine–where all they would have to give up is a chunk of free will.

But he doesn’t, he chooses instead to offer himself as an example of how people should live their lives, and hope humanity will get there on their own. It’s noble, sure, but that choice always rubbed me the wrong way.

You know who had the right idea? This guy.

4 thoughts on “‘Superman vs. the Myth of Aristocracy’ on Tor

  1. Catana

    Superman is a physical superman and a mental wimp. How much experience with humans does it take to realize they hardly ever learn anything by example. Or by hard personal experience. Maybe that’s why most of my fiction deals with various forms of slavery. Kneel!

    1. Always nice to meet another Zod fan 🙂
      You’re right – he persists with his failed methodology despite constant evidence that it’s not working. While I’m not totally familiar with the Superman timeline in the comics, I’m pretty sure there’s no ‘ending’ where humanity suddenly starts playing nice and Earth no longer has problems. So his plan is basically a complete failure.
      Thanks for commenting!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.